Fake abduction could lead to criminal charges

On Behalf of | Aug 15, 2023 | Criminal Law |

The operations of the police are serious and costly, and the public safety is at stake when police officers are conducting investigations and responding to reports from civilians. That is why it is against the law to provide false information that causes law enforcement to act in certain ways. Recently in Alabama, a young woman allegedly disappeared from the side of the road, which triggered a massive search effort and law enforcement operation to determine where she was.  

After several distressing days, during which people donated money, supported the family and helped search for her, the woman reappeared at her family home. After several days, it became clear that no one had ever actually abducted her. There is now speculation that the woman could face criminal charges for her role in the operation 

Admitting to a fabrication 

The woman has admitted that the entire abduction was a situation she fabricated. No one had ever taken her, and she never saw a child walking along the side of the road as she had reported when she made the initial call to 911. After her reappearance at her family home, the Hoover Police Department stated that they were considering filing criminal charges against her. They eventually charged her with falsely reporting an incident and falsely reporting to law enforcement authorities. Both of these are misdemeanor offenses. 

If the court convicts her of these crimes, she could face penalties that may include up to one year in jail and a $6,000 fine. The police stated that her actions led to concern across the greater Birmingham area. The court released her from jail after she posted bond, and police say that they are still unsure of where she was during the more than 48 hours she was missing. Due to the nature of the law, the court can only charge her with a misdemeanor offense. However, she has the right to vigorously defend herself against any allegations she is facing. 

The rights of the accused 

The case involving Carlee Russell garnered significant media attention in Alabama and across the country. While in the eyes of many, she should be facing more serious criminal charges, the law does not allow her to face charges for anything more than a misdemeanor. Regardless of the details of the case, she has the right to a presumption of innocence, the right to defend herself against any criminal allegations and the right to confront any evidence brought by the prosecution. 


FindLaw Network